Super subtle, natural eyeliner for your male and female sims. Found in TSR Category 'Sims 4 Female Eyeliner' | Natural eyeliner, Eyeliner, Sims 4 cc makeup
The Sims Resource - Dagger Liner - Eva Zetta
Sperm be gone": people hate The Sims 4's new eyeliner, so they've modded it out | Rock Paper Shotgun